Monday, February 12, 2007

Gardasil vaccine debate

When I was pregnant with my daughter, I joined a little group (July Firecrackers) of first-time expectant mothers to share our experience and questions with one another. Seven years later, the group still exists sharing stories and questions and victories and trials. It's a great group of women that I consider friends.

One of the latest topics for the group was regarding the new mandate in Texas. Starting in 2008, all girls entering the sixth grade must receive the HPV (Gardasil) vaccine. Since this can be considered a hot topic, I am quite impressed with how well my fellow Firecrackers have conducted their discussion of the subject.

First of all, it is my belief that government should not require such a vaccine. While, yes, this vaccine will prevent most HPV transmissions that could lead to cervical cancer, HPV is only transmitted by sexual contact, not general contact that occurs in schools.

Government mandates aside, I'm really on the fence about the vaccine. It's great that modern science has advanced to include this vaccine, but is it really necessary? What's wrong with abstinence?

One of the mom's on the group stated she would probably have her daughter vaccinated, but not tell her daughter what it is for. While I respect her discretion, it seems odd to not explain to your daughter why she is getting a shot. Shouldn't we be honest with our kids? Shouldn't our kids be honest with us?

Growing up, one would consider me a "goody-two-shoes". For the most part I was pretty honest with my parents. Before I did anything questionable, I often thought, "What would happen if my parents found out?" Hence, there really wasn't much to hide. Plus, I really didn't date much in high school. Once I got into college, my only significant other has become my husband. Again, really not much to hide from my parents.

So trust is what I am working on with my daughter right now...that we can have the kind of trust that she will feel comfortable to talk with her dad and me. While the two of us have a few things in common (stubborn, love music, and loving spirit) there are a number of differences. She is much more outgoing than I ever was at her age. It seems to me that I will need to give this some real consideration as she gets older. However, that will be about 8 - 10 years from now...I hope.

No comments: